Confession: My early days of makeup (circa 2008) kept me away from cream eyeshadow for practically an entire decade. They were sticky, oily and crinkly on my eyelids in exactly three minutes (eye primer wasn’t much of a thing back then – dark times, I know). It wasn’t until a few years ago that I finally gave cream eyeshadow a second chance and realized that these formulas obtained way better since my college days. Not only can I easily pat them on with my (clean!) finger, but I don’t have to spend 10 minutes buffing and blending because today’s formulas are silky smooth, blendable, and surprisingly long-lasting.
It sounds too good to be true, but believe me, I’m a complete convert now. So if you’ve felt chained to your powder eyeshadow palettes and crave an easier makeup routine like me, please tiptoe into the world of eyeshadows cream eyeshadow for me, k? Below are the 13 best cream eyeshadows that i highly recommend for your understated makeup days and your bold makeup trend days. But before you get overwhelmed with the choices (you have everything from drugstore eye shadow to splurge-worthy choices), let’s narrow down your options, starting with:
How to choose a cream eyeshadow
Look at the color and pigment
A few cream eyeshadows tilt to the sheer side, giving you a wash of color that’s perfect for anyone who likes light, subtle makeup. Other Cream Formulas can pack in pigment with just a few swipes of your finger or an eyeshadow brush – perfect if you like to be big and bold. If you can test the product in store, compare the pigment intensity by blending it on the back of the hand. But if you’re shopping online, be sure to read reviews, look at customer photos, and, hello, listen mewho’s broken down each of the best cream eyeshadows for color and pigment, below.
Consider the formula
Be honest with yourself: If you’re new to makeup and very pigmented or shimmery eyeshadow seems intimidating, opt for a stick formula that will allow you to shade your eyelid like a coloring book and control exactly where you drop the color. And if you hate all makeup brushes and applicators, opt for a pot or cream eyeshadow palette so you can use your fingers (again, wash them first!) to dab and blend.
Ready for the breakdown? Keep scrolling or pause here for a preview of what to expect:
Our Top Cream Eyeshadow Picks of 2022
Ready to get started? The complete breakdown, to come.
Best Multitasking Cream Eyeshadow
Danessa Myricks Beauty Pigment cream for eyes, cheeks and lips Colorfix
Anything multitasking has my vote, and that includes this cheek, lip and eye tint from Danessa Myricks, which comes in a really wide range of matte, metallic and high-gloss finishes. It’s also great if you like to keep a makeup bag to match, as it’s an all-in-one product. Example: The Sweet Pink Matte shade (pictured) or the Primary Red shade can work as a cream eyeshadow, liquid blush, and tinted lip gloss for simple monochromatic makeup.
Best Shimmer Cream Eyeshadow
Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Shadow
Check out the cream eyeshadow that rightfully converted me. This little shimmer stick is more than easy to apply (I glide it over my lids very quickly and pat it with my fingertips) and leaves me with the prettiest, lightest subtle finish that stays in place all day.
Best Cream Eyeshadow for Makeup Pros
Make Up For Ever Flash Color Palette Multi-Use Cream Color Palette
Makeup lovers, welcome to your new favorite cream eyeshadow palette. the creamy formulas will give you all the control and powerful pigment you need for the cool makeup looks you’ll definitely post to your grid (it’s never too early to practice your Halloween makeup). Pro Tip: To ensure the color doesn’t budge for hours, start with a primer and finish with a setting spray to hold it in place.
Best cream eyeshadow for beginners
Bobbi Brown Longwear Cream Eye Shadow
The best part about this cream eyeshadow, other than it doesn’t smudge or crease, is that it is a stick formula, which facilitates the application. So if you’re a makeup newbie or just refuse to spend more than 30 seconds on your eyeshadow (hello, same), you can just guide this cream eyeshadow stick over your lids and blend with your fingertips. fingers.
Best Pigmented Eyeshadow
Rare Beauty Stay Vulnerable Liquid Eyeshadow by Selena Gomez
If you’re looking for intense pigment, you’ve found the right eyeshadow. Dab the applicator on the back of your hand like a makeshift palette, then apply tape and dab a tiny bit of eyeshadow onto your eyelid. You’ll be surprised how much color a little of this silky formula gives you.
Best Metallic Liquid Eyeshadow
One/Size by Patrick Starrr Eye Popper Sparkle Vision Liquid Eyeshadow
Channel your interior Euphoria makeup with this ultra-pigmented metallic cream eyeshadow (which comes in five shimmering shades). Apart from the formula and the color, you’ll love how easy the tube and applicator are to pack that you can just carefully paint over your eyelid in one coat for a bold moment.
Best cream eyeshadow to build
Em Cosmetics Cosmic Pearl
Some days you want a full face, and some days you just want a little shimmer on your lids. Enter: This super customizable cream eyeshadow. Glide on with your fingertips (or use a flat eye shadow brush, if you’re ~civilized~) for a light shimmer wash, or apply a few more coats for a highly pigmented metallic finish.
Best Drugstore Cream Eyeshadow
Revlon ColorStay Cream Eyeshadow
Honestly, the fact that this long-wearing cream eyeshadow is less than $10 and comes with a handy little eyeshadow brush is quite excellent. The drugstore formula also comes in 12 shades, including this shimmery green.
Best Cream Eyeshadow with SPF
Supergoop Shimmershade Illuminating Cream Eye Shadow SPF 30
Guess what? Your eyelids also need sun protection. That’s where sunscreen makeup (and that eyeshadow) comes in – not only does it give your lids the perfect wash of color, but it is also boosted with SPF 30 to help protect your eyelids from harmful UV rays.
Best Multitasking Eyeshadow Stick
NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil
Simplify your makeup routine with this multitasking cream eyeshadow. The stick applicator allows you to wear the formula on your lids Where your lash line, and it is especially ideal for quick smoky eyes this spot, then stay put.
Best Shimmer Cream Eyeshadow
Hourglass Scattered Light Shimmer Eye Shadow
You know those days when you want to go beyond hell? Apply this ultra shimmer cream eyeshadow (I recommend using a brush unless you want to put glitter on your fingertips) For a full gold look (which, BTW, really lasts).
Best Subtle Cream Eyeshadow
RMS Beauty Eye Polish
Consider this cream eyeshadow your new go-to for quick touch-ups. The silky formula keep on going Great subtlethere, ideal for your soft-glam makeup. So feel free to dab it on your eyelids as you head to happy hour or your next Tinder date without fear of overdoing it.
Best Black Cream Eyeshadow
Stila Eyeshadow Pot
This creamy black eyeshadow is the key to creating the smokiest smokey eye. Smudge it over your lids with a fluffy brush, then line your lash line with an angled eyeliner brush. And, fun fact, it can be layered (and layered again) for the deepest shades of black.
This content is created and maintained by a third party, and uploaded to this page to help users provide their email addresses. You may be able to find more information about this and similar content on piano.io